31 July 2020

The big swing from 1950s to modern parenting – why we need middle ground

| Elka Wood
Join the conversation
Kids playing at Wallagoot Lake.

Reflections at Wallagoot Lake, south of Tathra on the NSW South Coast. Photo: Elka Wood.

I was talking to my friend, Nettie, last week and she told me that when she was about eight years old, she and her brother found a dead body, half-eaten by sharks, floating in the water near their home in Sydney’s northern beaches.

“We tried to tell an adult who told us, ‘It’s probably just a mannequin,'” she reflects. “So we found someone else to tell and they believed us. The police came and told us to rack off even though we’d been the ones to find the body.”

There was no question of going home because, as was common at the time, the rule at her house was that kids had to be out of the house until dinner.

“My mother would put a tea towel on the mailbox when we were allowed to come back inside,” Nettie says.

I’m blown away by her recollections and can’t help feeling that she wasn’t very well taken care of.

Where was the trauma counselling? Or at least talking it over with a loving parent?

“Oh no, children were seen and not heard,” Nettie confirms. “I tried to tell mum about the body but she didn’t listen. The only thing my parents would say to us at the dinner table was ‘sssh’ if we forgot that we weren’t allowed to talk.”

But Nettie and her partner, John, both feel they grew up in loving homes.

“We had good lives,” John says. “We never considered telling our parents anything, but we had our own lives. We had fantastic private lives.”

This is in stark contrast to my experience parenting and that of many of my peers, who overwhelmingly feel responsible not only for their children’s physical safety and wellbeing, but also for their mental health and minute-to-minute happiness.

We now know so much about all the ways children can be damaged, from suffering sexual abuse to bullying, that we feel increasing pressure to be omnipresent as parents to get them to adulthood unscathed.

Unfortunately, it’s not just our own feelings that guide the way we parent, but lashings of societal pressure – perhaps especially on women – which often lead to a river of guilt.

It’s a big swing from when Nettie and John were growing up.

This guilt leads to all kinds of weird behaviour, such as parents – like me – who ask their kids a zillion times a day, “You OK?”

As my kids get bigger, my biggest challenge is to leave them alone as I realise the frequent safety checks that were necessary when they were toddlers now only interrupt the flow of their play.

Mostly, we don’t need to give our kids more. The contradiction to the pressures of modern parenting is to back away and allow kids space to figure out how they feel about things on their own.

There’s such a fine line between giving kids airtime to talk things through and showing them you’re confident that they can handle it, whatever it is, by giving them time to explore on their own.

One thing I like to do is take my kids to a big open space and tell them I plan on making a phone call or reading a book or having a rest, and not to bother me.

The goal here is to be so boring that you force your kids to go and find their own fun/dead body while still being close by.

Of course, quality time with parents is important and I’d like to think that if my kids found a dead body, they’d tell me.

Until then, there’s nothing better than the sound of kids clattering in for dinner, wet and dirty, with their pants blown out at the knees.

And being ready to listen wholeheartedly because I’ve had hours of peace, of no questions, no tugs on my hands or clothes, and no indignant squeaking.

“Can you describe the dead person for me, darling? Where exactly did you see it?”

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

Sounds to me that this woman who wasn’t allowed to talk to her parents in the ’50s is more a child of uninterested parents than was the norm. I grew up in the ’50s as well & our dinner table was “the” place to catch up on each others’ day. As were most of my friends’ families. And I carried this tradition on with my children. If we had ever found a dead body I can guaran-damn-tee you that we would’ve told our parents! And would’ve been expected to as well. I see alot of differences in how today’s mums bring up their kids that I’m not fussy on & the biggest thing for me is that no-one gets punished these days for anything. I know the difference btwn right & wrong, I’m not sure today’s kids do. Not everything a child does deserves accolades, either, as then they think that the skies the limit as to the trouble they get into…if they never have to answer for it. Wow, you really got me started on THIS post. I’ll go now.

Samantha OLEARY5:52 am 19 Aug 20

That is good to know. I hate the term, seen and not heard. Today’s kids definitely need boundaries and discipline as did the generations before them. I have a baby right now, but I am raising him differently. I will spend quality time with him for sure, but there will also be rules, he will be taught right from wrong, and there will be punishment for breaking our rules, such as time out or grounding from things. I will not smother, but will very well be a part of his life. I will get to know his friend’s mom’s as well.

Nienke Haantjens7:30 pm 05 Aug 20

ha ha! a very good article and so true! things certainly have changed, some thingas are better, some not so much..

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.