14 June 2022

Recount request puts the brakes on Phillips' victory celebration in Gilmore

| Katrina Condie
Join the conversation
Andrew Constance and Fiona Phillips

Andrew Constance has demanded a recount of votes, putting a dampener on Fiona Phillips’ official poll announcement on Tuesday. Photo: Region Media.

Just two hours before Labor’s Fiona Phillips was set to officially claim victory, her Liberal opponent Andrew Constance has thrown a spanner in the works, requesting a recount of votes for the Federal seat of Gilmore.

Three-and-a-half weeks after the election, the final count saw Mrs Phillips ahead by 373 votes; however, Mr Constance says he has “strong grounds” for a recount.

“As counting has progressed over the last couple of weeks, my scrutineers have raised concerns in relation to certain aspects of the process, particularly the scrutiny of informal votes,” he said.

“Given the close result, I believe there are strong grounds for a recount and I have submitted a request to the Australian Electoral Commissioner.

“I will not be providing any further comment at this time while the Commissioner considers the request.”

Mrs Phillips cancelled her Tuesday afternoon press conference at the eleventh hour, saying “we have just received notice from the AEC that the declaration for Gilmore has been deferred and will not occur today as planned”.

The recount comes more than a week after the Albanese Government claimed victory over Mr Constance, a State Bega MP and former NSW Roads Minster.

READ ALSO Early snow spells bumper season start for some; causes season end for another

Ms Phillips snatched the seat from the Liberals in 2019 after the party vote was split between break-away member Grant Schultz, who ran as an independent, and Warren Mundine, who was parachuted in by then-Prime Minister Scott Morrison.

It’s been a tumultuous first term for Mrs Phillips, with Gilmore hit by bushfires, drought and flood, as well as COVID-19, but she says she has been a determined voice for her constituents in their time of need.

The strong result at the polls against one of the Liberals’ top guns is a reflection of Mrs Phillips’ on-the-ground approach.

She said the election campaign was a “pretty wild time”, and the wait for a result “has been pretty excruciating”.

“Andrew has been a local member for 18 years and a state minister, so it was never going to be easy,” she said.

A confident Mrs Phillips has already been meeting with the new Labor ministers in Canberra about visiting Gilmore.

“To finally have an opportunity to have direct input into things like housing and health is just phenomenal,” she said.

“To have access to first-hand information from the government is absolutely wonderful. I’ve already tapped some ministers on the shoulder and told them they need to come to Gilmore.”

Mrs Phillips said affordable and social housing were “pivotal to creating change” and were at the top of her agenda.

“We’re establishing the National Housing Supply and Affordability Council and working with state and local governments as well in terms of what we can do,” she said.

“The previous government has not taken any lead on that at all. If we can get that happening, well, that will be really exciting.”

READ ALSO Fishers back on the rocks after near-drowning at Malua Bay

She also proposes to target health, GP shortages and disaster mitigation, with plans to invite the new Minister for Housing, Homelessness and Small Business Julie Collins to Gilmore, as well as the Minister for Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, and Minister for Emergency Management, Senator Murray Watt.

Mrs Phillips says being part of a Labor government will give her a much louder voice in parliament.

“As a first-time MP, [the Liberal Government] didn’t share any information with me,” she said.

“Even during the bushfires, it was very hard to get information.

“Being an opposition MP was very, very difficult. The way I was treated was disgraceful. They cut me out of everything – every single thing.

“But I just tried to do what I could with the information I had.

“Now I’m in government, it’s going to be amazing.”

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

“AEC guidelines say a recount is conducted as a matter of course where the margin is less than 100 votes. Outside that, the AEC says a recount request must have “valid and specific grounds for supposing that it could change the result”, including the need “to identify specific ballot papers and associated significant counting process errors or irregularities that could change the result of an election within a division”.

“Frivolous requests for recounts, or requests due to dissatisfaction of the result, will be refused,” the AEC’s candidate’s handbook states.” Guardian 14/6/2022.

This may take a while….

Isabel Robinson10:24 pm 14 Jun 22

Please note that Andrew Constance was also FORMER State MP for Bega, having relinquished that position in order to pursue Federal politics, and forcing the electorate into yet another by-election (many voters having gone through the earlier by-election for Eden-Monaro after the resignation of Dr Mike Kelly, due to ill-health) in order to pursue his ambitions.
An extraordinary amount of the funding for the Princes Hwy upgrades over the past five years was centred more in the north, mostly in the large towns that fall into the Federal seat of Gilmore.
It’s hard not to be cynical.

Andrew needs another hobby…

Michael in the Bay5:10 pm 14 Jun 22

With the closest margin of all 150 seats in Australia and leading for most of the count I would be having a go at a recount too!

Mr. Constance was a very approachable and effective member for Bega for near 20 years, also a Minister in three portfolios.

Ms Phillips is a very nice person, however as a political advocate for Gilmore, especially the southern end, questionable. ‘Niceness’ doesn’t get you anywhere in Canberra.

Smart move! A few more should have a recount!

Donald J Constance Loser without grace!

Jeff de Jager8:03 am 15 Jun 22

or honour!

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.