16 June 2021

NSW Health cuts Eurobodalla hospital bed numbers, says Moruya doctor

| Hannah Sparks
Join the conversation
Dr Michael Holland

Dr Michael Holland has been campaigning for a new hospital for Eurobodalla since 2018. Photo: File.

A Moruya doctor says NSW Health has cut the number of beds intended for the new Eurobodalla Regional Hospital, which will replace Moruya District Hospital and Batemans Bay Hospital on the South Coast.

Obstetrician and gynaecologist Dr Michael Holland was involved in developing the new clinical services plan for the $200 million hospital at Moruya.

The March 2020 plan endorsed 165 overnight and day beds, including six paediatric beds, 16 emergency department beds and four maternity beds.

While this meant an increase in overnight and day beds from the 111 available at Moruya and Batemans Bay Hospitals, the number of maternity beds would be less than the seven available at Moruya.

READ ALSO Canadian firefighter moves to South Coast after assisting with bushfires

There was also no increase in the number of operating and procedure rooms, despite the fact the new hospital is intended to provide level four intensive care; emergency, general and acute medicine; general surgery; gynaecology and maternity services; and level three neonatal and paediatric medicine and surgery.

According to Dr Holland, local medical staff have been told the wards will be reduced by eight inpatient and 10 outpatient beds.

The number of maternity beds will also be reduced from four to three, paediatric beds from six to four and emergency department beds from 13 to 12.

“No sooner than the ink was dry on the 2020 Eurobodalla Health Service Clinical Services Plan, it was altered, if not erased,” Dr Holland said.

“It is not recognisable as a plan to deliver level-four clinical services to the population of the Eurobodalla.”

The Eurobodalla Shire has the second-largest population in the Southern NSW Local Health District and the second-highest number of births outside Queanbeyan.

The region also has the highest number of older and Indigenous residents.

People standing on vacant land

Celebrations greeted the announcement of the new Eurobodalla hospital site in December 2020. Photo: Alex Rea.

“The emergency department sees over 30,000 presentations compared to 19,000 at South East Regional Hospital (in Bega) and 23,000 at Queanbeyan,” Dr Holland said. “It is counterintuitive that a population of this size, with the consequent high number of clinical services, would have beds and proposed services reduced.

“Using maternity services as an example, 380 women per year book to give birth within the Eurobodalla, which receives women and babies from Milton to Ulladulla, to Bermagui and Cobargo.

“Approximately 330 births occur locally. An increase to level four maternity and level three neonatal services would reverse the transfer of nearly half of those women and babies outside the region.”

Eurobodalla’s health service currently sends more than 40 per cent of all patients to hospitals outside the region because services cannot be provided locally.

Dr Holland said NSW Health’s new plan could also mean there won’t be a paediatric service to care for the region’s children as the reduction of paediatric beds will make it difficult to recruit paediatricians and paediatric nurses.

“The waiting time for paediatric consultations is already 12 to 18 months on the South Coast,” he said.

Dr Holland is also concerned about the level of care for patients requiring surgery due to fewer inpatient and outpatient beds.

READ ALSO Deputy PM says Moruya bypass won’t impact funding for Eurobodalla Hospital

“If the health service is to provide the increased number of surgical procedures by reversal of flow of breast cancer surgery, colorectal surgery, general surgery and orthopaedics, how will the same number of operating theatres and a reduction of surgical beds allow for this?” he asked.

“How will the Eurobodalla keep the medically unwell patients without a physician-led, close observation service and an intensive care specialist-led ICU?

“The answer is a proposed Coastal Network Plan, which has not been seen by doctors, nurses or midwives. A plan that the community has not been consulted on.”

Dr Holland said the Coastal Network Plan will continue to send Eurobodalla residents outside the region for health care.

“The population of the Bega and Eurobodalla Shires both require the provision of high quality, timely and accessible health services,” he said.

“Cutting beds and services in the revision of the Eurobodalla Health Service Clinical Services Plan and directing the population of the Eurobodalla to Bega is not the answer.

“The answer is the adequate funding for capital works and operational costs for doctors, nurses, midwives, allied health and hospital service staff at both sites.”

The NSW Government announced the site for the new hospital in December 2020 and work is expected to commence soon.

NSW Health has been contacted for comment.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
Denise Brown8:34 am 18 Jun 21

How crazy is this …. it’s lovely to have a new hospital built in our area which is meant to replace two existing hospitals but if the entire capacity is less than the existing what is the point? Bricks and mortar can make a place look good but what counts is what is behind those bricks and mortar ….after all the time we have waited to even have this hospital agreed upon it really seems like such a complete waste of resources ….let’s just make it real people ….we are a mixed population including quite a large senior citizen component ..are we still going to have to travel interstate to Canberra to have the basics done …not happy!!!

Bernadette Brandes7:52 am 18 Jun 21

So disappointing. Hard work and many hours of work with preparation put in by so many. Now it seems we have been disregarded…again.
We will possibly have less service than what we have now…

Yet again the NSW government tries to duck out of its responsibilities to provide hospital care at the same level that the population of Sydney takes for granted. There has never been equal access to hospital care for rural and regional communities and this is reflected in poorer health outcomes. This has been exposed recently by the horror stories presented to the NSW Upper House enquiry on regional hospitals. If $1.5 billion can be found to move the Sydney Powerhouse museum then sufficient funds can be found in the NSW budget for a hospital which meets the needs of the Moruya and surrounding regions.

Many aged people do not have family to take them to hospital to Canberra where most specialists are. Without a level 4 hospital this region”s people will suffer and life shortened without that care

Sadly from personal experience, Lyn, Canberra may not be the answer either. I think Sydney is the better option by far.

Andrea M Charlton2:33 pm 17 Jun 21

I can’t understand why health services that are so desperately needed on the South Coast should be cut before they are even built! It’s a lot like putting in a 25 metre pool where a 50 metre one is needed – surely no government would do that? Oh, wait, that’s what happened at Batemans Bay…

Linda Steadman2:13 pm 17 Jun 21

Excellent inclusion in this newsletter, with concise information the community really needs to know about Thank you.

Because the State Seat of Bega is a safe Liberal Party seat, and the people repeatedly vote a person of Constance’s merit and character, the Government knows it can treat the people of the Electorate as they like.
I won’t be holding my breath waiting for the hospital even to be built, with one bed capacity.

Take the money from the Bypass and put that into building a state of the art new hospital If they choose the Yellow option not the Orange option the savings from building a 2.5k elevated highway rather than 5.5k as with the Orange option will give us enough spare change to build a realistic hospital

Carol Barton11:43 am 17 Jun 21

This is more than sad to hear. From the figures you have stated it seems they are being more than short sighted. We will keep the pressure up to get a proper 4th grade hospital. Thanks for your tireless and endless work Dr. Holland.

Narelle Frater8:59 am 17 Jun 21

This is ridiculous if they think they should cut back on bed numbers, when new hospitals are built it just common sense to improve and increase on what you already have as the new hospital has to cater for future growth in the area for many years to come.

Frank Grigson8:14 am 17 Jun 21

I made a decision to build and retire down in Tuross due to a number of things, not least the new hospital. I might as well have remained where I am. Too late, she cried. Premier please respond to the allegations! You cannot Welch on a promise.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.