12 June 2020

"Bizarre" email attack on McBain denounced by all sides and the Catholic Church

| Dominic Giannini
Join the conversation
Bega Valley Mayor Kristy McBain

Labor candidate for Eden-Monaro Kristy McBain has been targeted by emails purporting to be from the Catholic Church. Photo: Ian Campbell.

A bizarre series of emails with purported links to the Catholic Church claiming that God has forsaken Eden-Monaro have been denounced by candidates from all major parties and by the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference.

In an attack that appears to mirror the campaign against independent Wentworth candidate Dr Kerryn Phelps last year, the emails allege that Labor candidate Kristy McBain trained witnesses “to wrongly accuse priests to get pay-offs”.

One email attacked both former Bega Mayor, Ms McBain, and former Eden-Monaro MP Dr Mike Kelly, for their “witch hunt against our Catholic Church” and urged voters to vote for Liberal candidate Fiona Kotvojs to restore order to the region.

The emails have been sent to seemingly random recipients and claim to be from Catholic parishes, dioceses and other organisations. The authors appear to have created fake email addresses using legitimate or seemingly legitimate domain names, although the Church says there is no evidence that their internal databases or servers have been compromised.

Ms McBain, Ms Kotvojs and the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference (ACBC) have all denounced the emails, calling them wrong, offensive, inappropriate and malicious.

“The claims in these emails are wrong, false and offensive,” Ms McBain told the ABC. A statement from the ALP’s National Secretary Paul Erikson said the emails were “particularly offensive to the communities of Eden-Monaro that have lost so much during the Black Summer bushfires”.

Dr Kotvojs also strongly denounced the emails.

“I fully condemn this email. It is offensive and inappropriate. There is no place for this sort of thing in our politics or in our society,” Dr Kotvojs said.

The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference called the emails “criminal” in nature while conceding that since they don’t seek money or personal details, they may not meet the threshold for a police investigation.

“The content in the small number of emails that have been forwarded to us is offensive, unChristian and, in some cases, defamatory,” Fr Stephen Hackett, general secretary of the ACBC, said in a statement to the ABC.

“The views expressed in the emails we have seen do not in any way reflect the views of the Catholic Church, nor the organisations that are purported to have sent them.”

The emails allege that George Pell’s accusor, Witness J, is Kristy McBain’s half-brother and has died, and that God is punishing the electorate with bushfires, and Dr Kelly, as recompense for denying Pell’s innocence.

There is no evidence to suggest Witness J has died and Dr Kelly sustained his injuries while serving in the Middle-East with the Australian Defence Force before entering Federal Parliament in 2007.

The emails have been referred to the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC), but the Commission says it cannot do anything about them.

Parallels are being drawn to the homophobic emails which were during the 2019 Federal election attacking independent candidate Dr Kerryn Phelps running in the seat of Wentworth.

Some emails urged voters to support her Liberal opponent Dave Sharma, who strongly denounced the emails at the time.

Email against Ms McBain

One of the emails purporting to be linked to the Catholic Church. Photo: Hamish McDonald Twitter.


Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

I’ve just been checking my spam emails and received 3 of these type of emails….2 of them accusing Ms McBain of being a pedophile and keeping children in her basement for men to use – neighbours could apparently hear them calling out! I was just looking for her email address to let her know but it seems i am not alone and someone has been caught and charged. Pretty low and obvious spam.

The problem witb this is, that like all scam emails, it only needs 1 in 1000 to believe what it says to swing the by-election in the Libs favour.
Why can’t we control this sort of stuff? After all, we have given away our individual privacy by allowing the Government access to our metadata. Could it be that the current Government doesn’t really care because it benefits them?

I received on of these emails and deleted it because it was obvious that Catholic Org wouldn’t send an email of this nature. Seems some people have nothing better to do with their time. Let the candidates battle it out and whoever is the people’s choice will get in.

I got one of these. I’m in Victoria and have no interest or idea in who or what Kristy McBain stands for. But the email was ludicrous. BTW, it was sent from an email address, allegedly that of Avi Yemini. No idea if that’s the real email addy of Yemini.

Truly sick stuff. For the record let me state that I have never commented on the Pell case in any public space, forum or communication or even in private. I have regarded that matter as one entirely for our justice system and always refrain from commenting on people or issues subject to those processes. Mike Kelly.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.