26 June 2025

Wagga MP to introduce new law to end protections of Snowy Mountain brumbies

| By Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
10
Joe McGirr giving a speech

Wagga MP Joe McGirr was praised by enviornmental groups for his stand. Photo: Parliament of NSW Facebook.

Wagga MP Joe McGirr announced this week his intention to introduce a bill to parliament aimed at lifting restrictions on the culling of wild horses at Kosciuszko National Park.

Dr McGirr’s bill seeks to repeal former deputy premier John Barilaro’s Kosciuszko Wild Horse Heritage Act, which recognised the heritage value of the brumbies and sought to preserve their presence in the Snowy Mountains.

“Horses cause major damage to the alpine landscape, trampling wetlands and destroying habitat so it makes no sense to continue with a law that effectively requires that damage to continue,” Dr McGirr said.

READ ALSO Tapped phone call unravels former Wagga MP found guilty of misleading corruption inquiry

He argued that the Barilaro bill, introduced in 2018, effectively gave priority to the protection of horses – a damaging invasive species – over the preservation of native flora and fauna in the national park.

“We would never accept a law that prioritises the protection of wild pigs, goats or foxes over native species yet under the current law, we do just that for horses,” Dr McGirr said.

“It is time to reverse a wrong of the past and give the fragile high-country environment a chance to recover from years of degradation.”

Dr McGirr’s initiative follows the presentation to parliament in May of a petition signed by more than 11,000 people calling for the repeal of the Barilaro bill.

Environmental group the Invasive Species Council led the petition and is strongly supporting Dr McGirr’s repeal bill.

The council’s CEO, Jack Gough, said the repeal bill would give the parliament an opportunity to reverse years of environmental degradation in the park.

“‘For the sake of our native animals and precious mountain streams, we are calling on Premier Chris Minns and Opposition Leader Mark Speakman to come together to support Dr McGirr’s bill,” he said.

“Dr McGirr is showing real leadership and standing up for science, for nature, and for the public good.”

READ ALSO New overseas bat viruses with ‘pandemic potential’ spark calls for Australia to be prepared

The repeal bill is strongly opposed by the Brumby Action Group, who are dedicated to the preservation of the species and believe claims about wild horse damage to the ecosystem are exaggerated.

horses

The culling of horses in the Snowy Mountains has sparked heated debate. Photo: File.

The group has an active petition on website change.org calling for a ban on the shooting of brumbies, which has garnered more than 200,000 signatures.

“Brumbies hold significant cultural and social value for most Australians. Today’s wild-living brumbies are bloodline descendants of war horses,” the petition states.

“Brumbies have featured in books and film. Who hasn’t read The Silver Brumby or The Man From Snowy River or seen the film?

“We must find ways to respectfully conserve surviving wild-living mobs of brumbies, failing which we tear down not only innocent sentient creatures but the connection our Light Horsemen had with brumbies.”

The NSW Government states that while culling efforts have reduced the numbers of wild animals at Kosciuszko National Park, some 3000 to 4000 animals remain.

“Feral horse numbers in the park are finally trending downward. No one likes to see animals killed but this is the tough decision we have to make to protect our wildlife,” NSW National Parks Association CEO Gary Dunnett said.

“We’re already seeing early signs of ecological recovery – but unless this law is repealed we will still have over 3000 horses trashing one third of the national park. Now is the time to finish the job.”

Original Article published by Oliver Jacques on Region Riverina.

Free, trusted local news delivered direct to your inbox.

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Capital region by signing up for our free daily newsletter.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

10
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

It’s sad to think that anyone who says they love wildlife like knp could be so cold hearted do they realise that the Brumbies are wild life and that they hurt and feel to how would they like it if someone rounded up there children and shot them penny sharpe is a liar and manipulater that probley getting paid off to make that decision not half obvious

Marilyn Nuske misses the point entirely in her comments. Of course this is politics and it is about repealing flawed and corrupt legislation. Will it get the support needed? Probably not but to say the focus should be on pigs, deer and other ferals instead of horses is totally misleading. All other feral animals have been heavily targeted for years without objection and the only reason horses are contentious is because a small group of people who fantasise about romance movies and poetry believe horses are more important than native animals. They argue there is no evidence to show horses cause damage but have they actually been out to look? I would bet Marilyn hasn’t. I have seen the damage caused in real time. Not photos or video but actually watching the horses cause the damage. I have also seen the damage increase over time. It is not just about native wildlife. We need to protect the entire ecosystem which includes the waterways and grasslands. Marilyn, you have often used the word symbiotic to describe the horses relationship with the ecosystem and biodiversity. You should look up what that actually means because this introduced animal is changing the landscape to the detriment of the environment. Hardly symbiotic.

He should but out and focus on running his electorate these horses should not be any concern of his, so but out joe and get back to running your wagga electorate, other wise you have no compassion for these animals what so ever, for some one to even think of trying to pull this stunt of has to be a horse hater, it shows he does not listen to members of his electorate and goes ahead with this act of cruelity on these poor animals, as so far 81 % of these no votes are against you joe, so please listen to the people in your electorate.

Stop The Obviously Cruel Brumby Cull7:44 pm 26 Jun 25

Wouldnt it be a nice change to see About Regional Articles quoting people who have NOT been proven to have lied about this Brumby Cull, instead of those that have like Sharpe MP McGirr MP Gough Groom Swain ISC and Fleming (ex Parks). Why do you not see that the high estimated population figure used to bring in terribly cruel Aerial Shooting was exaggerated by more than 10,000 Horses when you understand that the number of horses removed since was about 8,000 since, and they say that there are about 3,000 (more like 1,500) left. Even if you take on board the oft repeated figured used by them of abt 18,000, thats still 6 to 7,000 ‘Ghost Horses’ they lied about to bring in Aerial Shooting. And thats using their own data and Surveys . Can you not see the total lack of credibility here of those whos propaganda you share (often) ?

Marilyn Nuske4:49 pm 26 Jun 25

McGirr needs to focus on Deer and Wild pigs, foxes and wild cats that are breaking mayhem across the State.
There is no evidence to prove removing brumbies will save any endangered species, nor has a brumby impact statement ever been completed.
The Brumbies have been living in the high country for 200 years, and do so symbiotically with all wildlife.
Brumbies belong in the high country, they are part of our culture heritage, they hold social value, stop trying to wipe out all European history in this country.

Marilyn Nuske4:43 pm 26 Jun 25

Brumbies hold Heritage value which was recognised by Parliament in 2018 when it voted to protect that value in Legislation. Unlike wild pigs and deer, they don’t hold Heritage value, McGirr is playing politics.
Legislation can work when managed. The Legislation gives power to NPWS to manage the Park and Brumbies adopting non lethal methods, if necessary.
It’s not necessary. Up to 3,000 May live across four retention zones.
McGirr needs to go back to basics

The bill should never have been introduced and yes should be scrapped/repealed. The bill showed how influenced Barilaro was by a vested interest who boasted ‘that they wrote the bill’. Barilaro proved how incompetent he was.
Of course the pro brumby group again spouting lies & misinformation and questioning the science.

Dr Hein Vandenbergh4:26 pm 27 Jun 25

I totally agree that it’s high time that a dagger should be taken to Barilaro’s brainfart. That said, he wasn’t all bad. A lot more was done under his – separate – Dept of Regional NSW, which had a very clear and beneficial focus on rural needs, with a substantial budget. The first thing Labor did was to incorporate it into the Dept of Primary Industry, where it is floating around in a kind of general morass, with a rather inexperienced minister with no fewer than 3 portfolios. No good has come of this so far, and the regions’ neglect is a stain on the current government. This brumby legislative proposal, overdue though it is, is not sufficient to counterbalance Labor’s inadequate focus on other rural exigencies.

Stop The Obviously Cruel Brumby Cull6:24 pm 27 Jun 25

Geez thats Rich – We Lie hey ? Please tell me how the numbers you used to Slaughter stack up against those you now say are left, and feel free to explain the now missing (never there, 8,000 to 10,000 Ghost Horses) ? And please offer up a single image of a dead or injured Native Animal (or any Animal for that matter) that was caused by a Wild Horse/Brumby ? You wont, because you and those like you can’t. Because that is YOUR big Lie. Only one side is truthful here. Sadly the other side (your side) is what gets Reported using their organised well-funded Media/Propaganda Machine.

The brumbies are an important part of the ecosystem, the large grazers. Without this the Park will become overgrown and an immense fire hazard. Only so much prescribed burning can be done and not too frequently. Brumbies keep the soil and plants healthy. Without this stimulation the Park will lose its vitality and resilience. This will start to show in years to come. It will affect insects and many other species as well. Many countries overseas have realised this and are rewilding with wild horses. As usual Australia is way behind.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.