10 December 2024

Ending logging in the Eurobodalla 'would negate half of the shire's other emissions'

| Marion Williams
Join the conversation
6
four protesters holding anti logging signs in front of an ecotourism banner

Friends of the Forest (Mogo) have been holding ‘Emergency Forest Embassies’ at the corner of Larrys Mountain Road and the Princes Highway since 26 November to protest logging. Photo: Supplied.

If logging ceased in the Eurobodalla, it would reduce the shire’s annual greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 246,000 tonnes. That would negate more than half of its yearly total emissions of 396,000 tonnes from electricity, transport, agriculture, waste and gas.

These were claims that Joslyn van der Moolen made to Eurobodalla Shire Council at the regular public access on 3 December. Councillor Anthony Mayne was an apology.

Ms van der Moolen was prompted to speak because logging at Mogo State Forest started two weeks ago. The Mogo State Forest operation of 534 hectares is part of 110,000 hectares of public state forest that covers 31 per cent of the Eurobodalla.

Her first point was that page 11 of the council’s Climate Action Plan 2022-2032 put total GHG emissions for the Eurobodalla local government area at an estimated 396,000 tonnes in 2019/20.

The main sources of emissions were electricity (67 per cent) and transport (26 per cent), with agriculture and waste each contributing 3 per cent. That figure did not include GHG emissions from land-use change and forestry.

Ms van der Moolen then cited ZeroSE’s fact sheet that estimated GHG emissions from logging in the Eurobodalla shire at 246,000 tonnes.

“If we stopped logging, more than half of our shire’s emissions would be negated,” Ms van der Moolen said.

She was speaking as a member of Coastwatchers Association’s Forest Working Group and as community liaison for Friends of the Forest (Mogo). The latter group has been holding ‘Emergency Forest Embassies’ on the corner of Larry Mountain’s Road and the Princes Highway since 26 November to protest about logging in the Mogo State Forest.

Joslyn van der Moolen outside Eurobodalla Shire Council building

Joslyn van der Moolen outside Eurobodalla Shire Council building on 3 December to address councillors in the public access meeting. Photo: Supplied.

Ms van der Moolen next spoke of the need to protect the shire’s two new mountain bike trails from logging in the Mogo and Bodalla state forests.

The Mogo Bike Trails received $8 million in government funding and the Narooma Mountain Bike Hub in the Bodalla State Forest received $4.1 million. The funding for the two trails predominantly came from the Federal and NSW governments’ Bushfire Local Economic Recovery Fund.

A global mountain biking event, Sea Otter, will be held in Mogo next year, “yet these state forests aren’t protected from logging”, Ms van der Moolen said.

Ms van der Moolen said without protection from logging, the trails were at risk of being closed for months, and of being damaged. “To provide certainty for the industry, the forests must be protected for ecotourism and carbon capture.”

After her address, Councillor Mick Johnson asked what the logged trees were used for and where the timber came from for construction.

Ms van der Moolen said the majority of the logged trees became wood chips for export (35 per cent) and firewood (29 per cent). More than 80 per cent of timber for construction comes from pine plantations.

fallen trees in Mogo State Forest

Logging in Mogo State Forest began two weeks ago. Photo: Friends of the Forest (Mogo) Facebook.

Councillor Coleen Turner (Greens) asked about the impact on native animals.

Ms van der Moolen responded that Coastwatchers had found 10 greater gliders in the forest and not all of them were in protected areas.

“It is a very beautiful forest, and more than half of the shire’s emissions can be negated if we stop logging,” she said.

“Council is a key stakeholder in the mountain bike trails. The trails will get damaged,” Ms van der Moolen said. “They should be put in a forest preserved area like there is around the Old Coach Road on the way to Big Spotty in Brooman State Forest. The big trees we see taken down are hundreds of years old.”

Fiona McCuaig, who was addressing the council about necessary upgrades to the Old Highway for her conservation burial site Walawaani Way, said she used to see one logging truck a day from her property in Bodalla. She said it was now six or seven trucks a day.

“It increases the fire risk to this community,” Ms McCuaig said.

The conservation burial site is being planted to bring back the endemic forest habitat for yellow-bellied gliders and glossy black cockatoos, as well as trees for koala habitat.

“We are logging the Bodalla State Forest where there are koalas,” Ms McCuaig said.

Join the conversation

6
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Trish Hellier8:52 pm 09 Dec 24

It is so sad to see yet again the never ending attempt to rid our country of another industry. What would our shire and Bega Shire have done without these workers during the 20/21 bushfires. During the inquiry conducted at Eurobodalla Shire Council the acting CEO of Bega expressed his gratitude to the forestry worker and told the inquiry how many of these workers walked into a meeting in Bega as fires were heading toward their area and offered their help.
Thanks to the logging in Picnic Road and Benandarah area I believe this saved north Batemans Bay. These nay sayers need to take the time to see how the forest has regenerated three fold.
There is a flow on affect with employment in this industry that includes the truck drivers, fuel, equipment, equipment maintenance, office workers etc. Trish Hellier

Philip Creagh6:03 pm 09 Dec 24

Ms. Mills perpetuates a myth

At last review about 700 jobs in SE NSW were directly related to the Timber industry and about 2,200 were indirectly related. This is a significant component of the SE NSW workforce and, as Venn pointed out, would be a serious nett loss in income to SE NSW.

NSW Forestry Corp income was hit hard by Covid for two years and then a very wet 2023 which required much road maintenance.

However its worth remembering that NSW Forestry annualised grants amount to $5/hectare and NSW National Parks & Wildlfe is $55/hectare (2022). NSW Forestry performs all the functions of NPWS as well as permitting made Mountain Bike trails (how many in National Parks = zero) and much more freedom to take your dog, camp and generally be more accessible than the NSW National Park system.

Philip Creagh11:10 am 08 Dec 24

Unfortunately the claims by Ms van der Moolen in the article, and in her written presentation to Council, are riddled with the usual hyperbole and attacks on the timber industry that are typical of a Greens agenda for the south coast.

Quoting extensively from the Frontier economics report (Macintosh) she has not applied any critical analysis, fortunately others have. I

n a rebuttal to Frontier economics by Tyron Venn in 2022 ( Review of the Cost-Benefit Analysis of Native Forest Management by Frontier Economics ) it was shown there are eight issues which demonstrated the Frontier report is biased.

Ms. Van der Moolen makes two main claims. 1. That stopping logging would reduce Eurobodalla’s GHG emissions and 2. that dedicated mountain bike tourism would be more profitable than the timber industry.
1. The emissions caused by logging is overestimated as the leakage factor applied by Macintosh did not factor in the carbon intensive alternatives to timber such as steel, concrete and carpet. Further the method of carbon accounting (life cycle assessment – LCA) has been biased to only include a partial carbon accounting. This is due to the fact that only one harvest event, not the long term implications of using forest products is used, not the regrowth of trees replacing logged ones.
Australian research has shown that using wood in their construction can halve the LCA.
2. The claim that mountain bike tourism will overtake the timber industry is incorrect. Mainly, the benefits of this tourism was not equated with the costs of providing the goods and services and secondly that the reduction in spending by forestry businesses was ignored. In short Venn demonstrated that much of Macintosh’s estimates was based on flawed data such as the halving of the industry employment from 700 to 290 jobs.

So few people employed in an industry that costs taxpayers to keep it going and destroys the habitat and forests that make our area so beautiful. And what for? 90% from our area ends up as woodchip. Such a waste. It needs to stop

Nick HOPKINS8:57 am 08 Dec 24

A well constructed summary of a timely issue… thanks Marion

Jenny Knowles12:53 pm 07 Dec 24

Sad entitled semi retired boomers. No to our Forestry jobs, no to timber for building, no to everything. What a waste of time the Greens really are.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.