31 October 2023

Discovery of starving foals in Kosciuszko National Park sparks outrage

| Edwina Mason
Join the conversation
foal in grass

One of the foals found in the southern end of Kosciuszko National Park at the weekend. Image: Shannon Byrne.

Update October 31, 11:00 am: The second foal found in KNP on Saturday by Shannon Byrne died early this morning.

A man who discovered two starving foals in Kosciuszko National Park says he is under no illusion the NSW Government is to blame.

On Saturday (28 October), local Shannon Byrne carried a weak foal 500 metres to a waiting car in a bid to save its life, while another foal followed behind.

Both colts, just under a week in age, had been discovered alone in the dense bushland south of Jindabyne by Mr Byrne as he was riding that morning.

Video footage of the foals widely shared on social media has resulted in an explosive reaction from animal welfare advocates.

“If it was one foal, I guess there’s a number of scenarios that could have occurred,” Mr Byrne said. “But to find two foals together like that just points to foul play, I wonder if there’s been an illegal cull but the fact is, it’s come to this.”

He, like other park users, has encountered countless orphans in recent months, some wandering into camps in search of food.

In the wake of NSW Environment Minister Penny Sharpe’s announcement that aerial shooting of feral horses will be permitted in Kosciuszko National Park, concerns have raged in the social media court of opinion those operations were already underway, despite categoric denials.

READ ALSO NSW Government sanctions aerial shooting of Kosciuszko’s wild horses

Mr Byrne is still dubious. He said orphaned foals were usually the result of bait and trap operations where mares are lured by feed and become locked in self-closing purpose-built yards.

He is concerned that, with aerial shooting imminent, during foaling season, this is just the start.

“Had I left the poor buggers there they would have been torn apart by wild dogs,” he said. “That’s what happens.”

Delivered into the hands of an experienced local carer, the weakest foal died Saturday night and the other is said to be battling.

horses in a yard

Wild horses in Kosciuszko National Park have been trapped using lures in recent years. This form of culling has resulted in mares being separated from their foals. Photo: File.

Mr Byrne’s great-grandmother was the first white woman to cross the Snowy Mountains and his family have held land there since the 1840s. Having ridden in the mountains two to three times a week for most of his life, this bushman’s knowledge of KNP is second to none.

With generations of his family living side by side with the wild side of the mountains, where corrobboree frogs used to proliferate alongside the thousands of grazing sheep and cattle and wild horses frequently, caught, trained kept or sold, he’s well placed to comment on the issue.

He said he has no time for politics but is damning of the management of the park by NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS).

“They behave like a law unto themselves, they will do what they want, they always have here and now it’s got to the point where it’s out of control,” Mr Byrne said.

And by out of control, he says wild horses are the least of their problems.

On Saturday’s four-hour ride, Mr Byrne says he encountered four colts.

“Here it’s rough and there’s a natural attrition that takes care of the horses but even in the north of the park, there’s nowhere near the numbers like they’re saying, you’d be lucky if you found 1000 horses up there now.”

READ ALSO NSW Government ‘ignored’ post-fire panel advice on wild horses

He also sees the weeds, bogged waterways caused by hundreds of deer, pig rippings and 20 years of unfettered, unmanaged grasslands that now render some parts of the park a tinderbox.

“Look at the Corroboree Frog, years and years of grass laying over forming a mat creating an intolerable humid acidic environment and frogs with a fungal disease they’re blaming on climate change,” Mr Byrne said.

“It’s catastrophic up here right now, and the NPWS are killing what they’re claiming to save, they say in the 2019-20 Dunns Fire 15 billion native animals were lost.

“The horses have been there their whole lives and didn’t cause the extinction of those animals but a fire will come along and wipe them out overnight.”

“It’s not the brumbies that are destroying this park. We’ve all lived up here in harmony for the best part of 150 years, but the NPWS have a lot to answer for in terms of what is happening up here,” Mr Byrne added.

“If we took the horses out, they’re still going to have 90 per cent of the environmental damage.”

Aerial culling, he says, isn’t the answer.

“I’m all for management but … shooting’s not right. I’ve seen deer littered with bullet holes, others who didn’t die instantly laying on the ground thrashing for days.

“There’s nothing humane about it, [NPWS] like to sugarcoat it and say one shot kills but one shot doesn’t kill.”

He says local people with generations of experience should be put back in charge of the park.

“Parks, politicians, conservationists, they can’t ride around and read the land like bushmen do.

“To see this situation time and time again – poor defenceless creatures left at the mercy of the bush – and knowing there will be more of it, I don’t care what anyone says, it’s inhumane.”

A NPWS spokesperson said aerial shooting, approved by the NSW Government on Friday, had yet not commenced within Kosciuszko National Park.

In relation to the discovery of the foals, the spokesperson said: “There was very little information from the social media video to determine its exact location, which indicates to be ‘the southern end’ however the NPWS has not undertaken any horse control operations in southern Kosciuszko National Park since early this year.”

“NPWS has not been provided any specific information regarding this alleged issue. If information is provided, NPWS will investigate”.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
Williams Duane9:11 am 05 Nov 23

From a macrobial level, I don’t believe that our soil is designed to support hooved life. Nor our vegetation. Our low lying plant life, are designed to hold the soil together, in drought, rather than feed pigs, cattle or horses. Being an animal lover, I’d like to support the unhampered existence of these magestic creatures, within this park. Being a realist, I’d say that there are reasons, no fish farms exist in the desert. The more we try to force nature’s hand, by eating veggies out of season, farming non native animals, or allowing pests to flourish, because we enjoy their ascetics, the further we venture from sustainable life, within that region. If our species is to survive, we might want to stop thinking like collectors, and start behaving like contributors.

Steve Chivers9:50 pm 01 Nov 23

A whole story to make the NPWS look bad based on one man’s suspicion, and at the end a small disclaimer that there’s no actual evidence to support the accusation against NPWS… Is this journalism or a social media rant?

patricia gardiner9:37 am 31 Oct 23

When aerial culling actually begins there will be follow up ground crews in the target areas.

patricia gardiner9:26 am 31 Oct 23

One must wonder who is actually playing ‘foul’.
Any responsible person would immediately report such an incident to authorities.

What’s wrong with this story? Two abandoned foals found but no evidence of any dead horses. Surely the expert bushman would have gone looking for the mums. You can see by the flattened grass the foals were in a horse camp area. No evidence of NPWS shooting in the southern areas and it is flatly denied by the service. This story is straight out of social media propaganda with an inference it was Parks shooting that caused the foals to be orphaned and zero evidence to back it up. More pro horse propaganda from this writer who is part of the social media supporting horses.

As for Mr. Byrne and his knowledge of the country, the frogs did quite well until white man introduced sheep, cattle, pigs, deer and lets not forget horses. Perhaps Mr. Byrne considers the horses are there for his pleasure and it would seem he has run a few down and thrown a rope over them. We have all seen the results of Mr. Byrne’s way of looking after the park in what he describes as harmony. Most thinking people will quickly discern his way only leads to destruction but it lines the pockets of those who would benefit from using the park as a paddock.

Quick question for Mr. Byrne. How many of your forebears shot feral horses because they were a pest? I would bet it was not done as humanely then as it is now.

patricia gardiner12:26 pm 31 Oct 23

Spot on Peter!

I agree, this looks like neglect in a private setting. Was this Bryne fellow alone at the time, and can anyone verify his claims?
Media Watch is full of shonky stories by people manipulating photos to back their cause.
The entitled attitude of those who use National Parks as their own paddocks and business ventures is deplorable.

David Bowley8:35 pm 30 Oct 23

This is outrageous. The RSPCA should prosecute the cold hearted minister who approved the inhumane slaughter of these beautiful animals. Surely they could be rounded up and rehomed.

I don’t think Mr Byrne’s comments that horses & other feral animals have lived in harmony is true. They got rid of the cattle due to the damage (lots of scientific data going way back to support this). Making conclusions of what happened to the foals dams is just speculation.
Perhaps look at the science that all feral animals are damaging our National Park. Didn’t the submission on Ariel shooting have a majority support, yes and ‘outrage’ on social media is not uncommon is it? esp without facts and level heads.

Stop The Obviously Cruel Brumby Cull5:51 pm 30 Oct 23

Thank you Shannon for your care and insight into this disgusting disgraceful Cull that is based on Lie after Lie (re numbers and damage) by Ms Sharpe Minns & Fleming after listening to the garbage dished out by the Swain Cox and Gough at the Invasive Species Council propaganda machine. Finally the truth is getting out there. Thanks for this article – this is the truth of the Cull.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.