4 November 2026

Questions over planning department's likely approval of Narooma foreshore development

| By Marion Williams
Join the conversation
5
The proposed development at 20 Gina Court is wider than a Boeing 737 MAX.

The proposed development at 20 Gina Court is wider than a Boeing 737 MAX. Photo: Supplied.

Eurobodalla Shire Council’s planning department seems likely to approve this week a development application for a large house and garage on Wagonga Inlet foreshore that seemingly fails several provisions of the Narooma Township Development Control Plan (DCP).

In early April council staff issued a formal request for further information on development application (DA) 0339/26, identifying DCP variations including garage site coverage and foreshore setbacks.

On 13 October, council performed a view-sharing and height-pole inspection at the neighbouring property, 18 Gina Court, which is owned by Julian Poulter. He showed planners several aspects of the DA that do not comply with the Narooma Township Development Control Plan (DCP).

The areas of non-compliance include its scale, such as its 38.55 m width. Mr Poulter said that was wider than the Narooma Sports Centre and would become the largest building on Narooma’s foreshore.

READ ALSO Proposed vet clinic to share site with refuge to help animals in need

At 161 square metres, the 4.69 m high proposed garage exceeds the DCP’s 60 square metre limit and is larger than a neighbouring property.

“Who needs a garage capable of storing 12 cars,” Mr Poulter said. “I’m all for development, but this is unnecessarily large and completely blocks our natural light and views.”

AI-generated image of the existing view of Wagonga Inlet foreshore and the view with the proposed dual occupancy building.

AI-generated image of the existing view of Wagonga Inlet foreshore and the view with the proposed dual occupancy building. Photo: Supplied.

Mr Poulter has requested that the DA be referred to councillors plus a notice of motion to raise awareness of how council uses its own planning instruments.

“If this DA goes through then the Narooma DCP will be worthless,” he said. “Approval would see Narooma foreshore turned into a concrete jungle yet the DA obviously fails the DCP.”

On 30 October, Gary Bruce, council’s director planning, housing and environment, wrote to Mr Poulter in response to letters he had written to council’s general manager and councillors in September and October.

“The amended plans have been further assessed by council officers and are now deemed satisfactory with regard to the DCP, including the principles of view sharing and the identified variations,” Mr Bruce said. “The assessment of DA0339/26 is now being finalised and is anticipated to be determined by Friday 6 November 2026 as approved under delegated authority by council’s division manager, development services.”

Mr Poulter said he had raised legitimate concerns with the council and Member for Bega Dr Michael Holland about how the various planning regulations were being used. “Now it seems Mr Bruce is in a hurry to approve the DA before those questions can be addressed,” Mr Poulter said. “The community should be concerned.

“Without a deferral and appropriate councillor scrutiny, the Narooma community risks being denied the opportunity to see its elected representatives defend the very planning instruments its council previously adopted,” he said.

“I believe Mr Bruce’s letter raises significant questions about the effectiveness of Narooma’s planning controls, particularly given the exceptional scale of the proposed development and the specific provisions of the DCP that appear to conflict with its design.”

The peak of the proposed development is more than halfway up the upper floor of a neighbouring property.

The peak of the proposed development is more than halfway up the upper floor of a neighbouring property. Photo: Eurobodalla Shire Council.

He also questioned why the DA would be determined so quickly after the amended drawings were received.

“The applicant was granted months of extra time to respond to council’s notice of variations and now we are given just a few days to respond. The whole DA process seems to be broken.”

READ ALSO Generous family home and village living right on Canberra's doorstep

Mr Poulter said the likely approval of a seemingly non-compliant DA was in the context of the new planning regime effective 1 September where councils no longer must notify neighbours or publicly exhibit DAs for dual occupancy, attached dwellings, dwelling houses, multi-dwelling housing, and subdivisions.

“Not only will residents be unaware of a DA until the bulldozers arrive next door, but also the DAs may be non-compliant,” he said. “People need to understand why this is such a dangerous precedent that will impact them directly.”

Furthermore, if a submission is lodged for any of those excluded types of development it is not considered a formal submission and need not be considered during the DA’s assessment.

On 8 September, the council’s acting assessment manager Katrena Fuller told councillors that was why it was very important that the council had strong and robust DCPs and policies that clearly defined what the council would and would not accept.

“This is the first indication that under the new regulations, council’s planning department will throw DCPs into the bin and neither the community nor councillors will have any influence on development,” Mr Poulter said.

Region asked the council why the planning department now deemed the DA satisfactory with regard to the DCP.

In a statement, a council spokesperson said the DA for a dual occupancy at 20 Gina Court was still under assessment.

“The application has been notified on two occasions following modification of the proposal by the applicant,” the statement said.

“The applicant has made a series of changes to the proposal to address council policy and concerns raised by neighbours.

“All development proposals are assessed on merit and in accordance with council policy.

“Once the assessment is finalised, the application will be determined in accordance with council procedure.”

The response did not answer why the DA was satisfactory with regard to the DCP.

Free, trusted local news delivered direct to your inbox.

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Capital region by signing up for our free daily newsletter.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

5
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

The planning and housing development across the shire is gridlocked and the people with the keys to unlock the gates is Council but will they?

The Federal and State Governments placed a strangle hold on development by passing legislation and stringent regulations on the Building Industry which created enormous financial burden on developers and construction companies as well as, adding additional costs to housing projects. The New Planning Guidelines rolled out in September are part of the Planning Reforms Act 2025, which were passed to enable local councils a clear passage to move forward with local planning and development across NSW. The issue arising at the local level however, is the lack of consistency across the Shire when we look at the new planning guidelines. If, Council staff are to be the drivers of change in our community rather than be seen as the enemy of the state, then there needs to be consistency across the board because staff cannot afford to be seen acting with blinkers on when they make decisions about how they process one development over another.

Reading the new DCPs highlighted the recent subdivision at 35 Dunns Creek Road. Under the Statewide CPP this DA would have been excluded and would not have needed to be considered as a formal submission during the assessment of the application. Therefore, it would not have been subjected to development approval by our elected representatives as the proposed subdivision was under 5 lots which would have made it exempt.

The solution going forward is very simple as it does seem that the local DCPs are now superseded. Most residents would expect Council staff to follow the NSW Government guidelines and assess each DA across the shire according to the criteria in line with councils planning policies, and not waiver under pressure from residents, neighbours and elected representatives. Councils have been given the right of passage to unlock the gates and keep our local economy ticking. All it takes is strong leadership.

Julian Poulter1:06 pm 08 Nov 26

I think you may have misunderstood. Neither the CPP or the Planning Reforms Act 2025 render other planning instruments such as DCPs inoperative. There is a clear hierarchy for state SEPP-LEP-DCP regulations but to imply it creates open season for development is incorrect. When you talk of pressure from residents, neighbours etc I think you are referring to the “The Community” which, last time I looked, votes for these policies. Those who live in this most beautiful part of the world of course want a functioning economy, but not at the expense of over-development. This isnt Sydney.

cannedbeeria5:00 pm 05 Nov 26

“The applicant was granted months of extra time to respond to council’s notice of variations and now we are given just a few days to respond. The whole DA process seems to be broken.”
Why is a system always “broken” when it doesn’t satisfy one applicant? It’s hasn’t been broken before. It’s a set of rules. Follow them and the DA will pass.
It’s only when people try to bend the rules that this type of trouble starts.

Julian Poulter9:13 am 08 Nov 26

Or they are applied inconsistently as in this case. In this case The Development Control Plan (DCP) is the rules and they state clearly that the bulk, scale and character of a DA need to be maintained. There are some numerical constraints where it is easy to compare but others where some judgement need to be made by a planning department. Our judgement is that a massive foreshore mansion larger than an aircraft hangar doesnt conform but it seems the planning department think otherwise!

It is no surprise the Planning Dept of ESC is ignoring the concerns of Mr Poulter as it has ignored the wishes of other residents on different matters. And Michael Holland would be no help at all so why waste time approaching him.

I had to question their mentality and business acumen when they placed a large statue of a gorilla on the beach foreshore at Batehaven. ????? Would this not have been more suitable outside Mogo Zoo? Some immature councillor’s idea of a joke?

I am sure there would be quite a few residents in Eurobodalla shake their heads at any ridiculous work the Planning Dept has performed close to them as I have.

Most of the intelligent people have resigned from the ESC and we seem to have been left with, in my opinion, those who have difficulty working out each morning which shoe goes on which foot and they would not be able to plan a dinner for two let alone any sensible planning for our Shire.

About Regional stated their question to ESC on this matter was not satisfactorily explained by the “spokesperson” and I think I know who this is. A typical run around explanation to absolve themselves from any future criticism.

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.