
Snowy Monaro Councillor Andrew Thaler has needed legal defence to fight eight claims made against him since entering office in 2024. Photo: Claire Fenwicke.
Questions are swirling over whether a Snowy Monaro Regional Council representative was allowed to bypass policy and access the insurer directly to cover his legal defence costs — which could total at least $1 million.
Andrew Thaler has defended himself against eight separate legal claims since becoming an SMRC councillor in 2024. These relate to bullying allegations, AVO submissions, code of conduct claims and appeals.
SMRC’s Payment of Expenses and Provision of Facilities for Mayor and Councillors Policy (first in place in 2022 and most recently redrafted on 10 November, 2025) outlines the situations whereby councillors can access the council’s insurance payouts.
“Reasonable” legal assistance can be indemnified or reimbursed by the council if a councillor is defending themselves arising from their performance “in good faith” under the Local Government Act, if defending themselves in defamation proceedings or when appearing before an investigative or review body — provided they win the case or haven’t been accused of corrupt conduct.
The council won’t pay the legal costs if the councillor initiates the proceedings or for proceedings that don’t involve the councillor performing their local office role.
“Reimbursement of expenses for reasonable legal expenses must have Council approval by way of a resolution at a council meeting prior to costs being incurred,” the policy stated.
It’s this line that has brought into question whether Cr Thaler should have had access to the council’s insurer’s money at all.
Recently published responses to questions on notice (asked by Cr Lynda Summers) couldn’t clarify how much the insurer had covered in Cr Thaler’s legal costs, nor whether consent for expenditure was obtained in accordance with SMRC’s rules.
“The information has been requested from Council’s insurance mutual. This will be provided as an updated response to this question on notice,” the document published on 11 September stated.
It’s also unknown how these payout costs will impact the council’s future insurance premiums — and ultimately the budget’s bottom line.
Nationals Upper House member Nichole Overall asked Local Government Minister Ron Hoenig during budget estimates what could happen to a councillor if they had not received the council’s “explicit approval” to make a claim on the insurance.
“It seems somewhat bizarre … I will have it pursued because there’s something unusual about what you’re suggesting,” Mr Hoenig responded.
Region asked whether Cr Thaler had indeed submitted claims to SMRC’s insurance company without approval from the council.
He said he didn’t need to.
“Council’s internal policy is irrelevant; it’s the insurer’s policy with council that counts at law,” Cr Thaler said.
“It’s interesting that both ACT Labor Councillor Lynda Summers and Nationals [Upper House Member] Nichole Overall are working together to shut down my legal costs to deprive me from having representation from, for example, the second-highest court in the land.”
Cr Thaler claimed SMRC’s policy was recently updated to include the line about needing permission from the council before accessing the insurer as part of an attempt to stop him from making claims.
The matter he referred to is before the Court of Appeal, where the NSW Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure wants to overturn a NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) decision that substituted his suspension for a reprimand.
If this suspension is found to be legally valid and is reinstated, Cr Thaler would reach the automatic threshold for disqualification under the Local Government Act and would be banned from holding a role in public office for five years.
Region contacted SMRC for comment but did not receive a response.














'Tiny homes' as a marketing brand name fall under the NSW definition of 'Moveable Dwellings' which… View