3 August 2026

Inquest returns open finding on fisherman who disappeared in 'horrible' conditions

| By Claire Sams
Start the conversation
boat anchored in a marina

Geoffrey James Buchanan was on this boat when he disappeared while fishing for tuna off Batemans Bay. Only the vessel was recovered in the search for the 56-year-old. Photo: Facebook.

A coronial inquest has been unable to identify the cause of death for a 56-year-old fisherman who disappeared in South Coast waters a year ago.

Geoffrey James Buchanan left Batemans Bay Marina on 19 July to fish for tuna aboard his eight-metre Arvor cruiser. He was reported missing after he failed to return from his trip.

Judge Doug Dick OAM, in his newly published findings, found that Mr Buchanan died “on or about” 19 July.

“It is always a distressing time for family and friends when an inquest is held into the circumstances surrounding the disappearance of a loved one,” he said.

“Sadly, questions will remain unanswered.”

READ ALSO Migrant worker allegedly underpaid almost $100,000 by Riverina supermarket

According to the inquest’s findings, Mr Buchanan bought his boat in 2023.

Judge Dick found that it had a 300-horsepower motor and while the boat could be used for fishing, it wasn’t “purpose- built” for offshore game fishing.

On 19 July, 2025, he was seen on CCTV leaving the Batemans Bay Marina on his boat.

“Mr Buchanan was known as a responsible boater who respected the sea, prioritised safety and exhibited sound judgment,” Judge Dick said.

During the trip, he sent a series of messages to his family and another fisherman, including photos and videos of his tuna catch and the sunrise.

In his final message to his wife, sent at 9:49 am, he wrote: “It’s horrible now, I’m heading in.”

Marine Rescue boat at sea

Marine Rescue NSW crews joined the search for Mr Buchanan. Photo: Marine Rescue NSW.

When Mr Buchanan did not return home, a multi-agency search was launched.

It involved Marine Area Command, Marine Rescue NSW, surf lifesavers, the Australian Maritime Safety Authority’s (AMSA) Challenger aircraft and military aircraft.

While search efforts initially focused on an area stretching from Ulladulla to Merimbula up to 12 nautical miles (22 kilometres) offshore, it was expanded to cover a zone from Port Stephens to the Victorian border.

In his findings, Judge Dick referred to evidence from an expert doctor, who said it was unlikely he could survive for more than about eight hours on the water.

“Having regard to air temperature, water temperature, sea conditions, wind strength, currents and Mr Buchanan’s medical needs, his expected survival would be six to eight hours,” he said.

“The best-case scenario was that Mr Buchanan could still be alive if he was in the boat and able to manage his diabetes, but that probability was small.”

That search was suspended after four days, when his boat was discovered about 80 nautical miles (148 km) east of Narooma.

Mr Buchanan wasn’t on board.

“Police concluded that notwithstanding the deteriorating weather conditions, Mr Buchanan continued to fish from the boat, which is not designed for that purpose, in weather that was worsening,” Judge Dick said.

“Police concluded that Mr Buchanan hooked another fish and while fighting to reel it in, has either fallen or been pulled overboard … With the boat still in gear, Mr Buchanan was unable to rescue himself.”

READ ALSO Community to have say on naming of Batemans Bay Bridge

He described the results of a forensic examination of the boat as “unremarkable” and noted that police did not consider Mr Buchanan’s disappearance suspicious.

Judge Dick said that while the exact route Mr Buchanan had taken couldn’t be determined from the boat’s internal system, its motor log showed that the vessel had travelled about 220 km at an average speed of 5.21 knots.

Judge Dick said it was unknown whether he was wearing a lifejacket, but he didn’t have a personal locator beacon.

He ultimately found that Mr Buchanan is dead “as the result of misadventure”, but was unable to determine a specific cause of death.

This means the inquest has returned an open finding.

He extended his condolences to Mr Buchanan’s family.

“I acknowledge and understand that uncertainty and lack of finality can make grieving especially difficult,” he said.

Free, trusted local news delivered direct to your inbox.

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Capital region by signing up for our free daily newsletter.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Start the conversation

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.