28 October 2026

Eurobodalla Shire councillors defer decision on 685-lot Broulee planning proposal

| By Marion Williams
Join the conversation
9
A map of the proposed development

A map of the proposed development. Image: Brightway Development Group.

Eurobodalla Shire councillors have deferred deciding on whether a controversial rezoning proposal in Broulee should proceed to the Minister for Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for a Gateway Determination and requested a supplementary report from staff within 90 days.

The shire desperately needs housing, particularly affordable and smaller dwellings. The planning proposal comes with promises of many community benefits through a Voluntary Planning Agreement (VPA) including 140 affordable, build-to-rent and key worker homes, and contributions to the costly necessary upgrade to the Tomakin Sewerage Treatment Plant. Some dwellings would be kit-style, likely delivering housing faster than by conventional building.

However, the proposal does not comply with council’s planning framework, would set a precedent for other developers, and potentially see the village’s population rise from 1947 to 3454.

The developer, Brightway Development Group, cited the July 2026 change in state legislation that permits proposals that respond to significant changes, such as demographic changes, that have not been recognised in the existing planning framework.

READ ALSO Broulee facing 685-lot growth as revised documents for planned community lodged

The planning proposal for 207 Broulee Road covers 125 hectares of land zoned RU1 – Agricultural Production and C2 Environmental Conservation. It seeks to rezone 62.14 ha of the RU1 land to R2 low density residential and expand the C2 zone to 30.82 ha. The R2 zoning would enable 293 dwellings on compact housing lots, 331 on standard housing lots, plus 61 other residential lots – totalling 685.

The developer’s previous planning proposal for 800 lots was refused by council and the Southern Regional Planning Panel in 2024.

Councillors wanted to understand what had changed from 2024 to make staff recommend the revised planning proposal, plus answers to the questions raised by community members in the public forum before the council meeting held this week.

The community and councillors also struggled with the process whereby the proposal goes for the Gateway Determination with only preliminary information on bushfire evacuation, road access, water and sewer infrastructure, flooding, wetlands, biodiversity and heritage. The detailed reports and community consultation follow the Gateway Determination.

An aerial photo of the proposed site

The 125.3 hectare site in Broulee. Photo: Brightway Development Group.

In the public forum session nine people spoke against the proposal and six people spoke in its favour, plus Brightway Development Group CEO Ed Fernon.

The six people included someone speaking on behalf of struggling young families, a long-term renter and a long-time resident who had seen a lot of change. “The question is always do we plan for it well,” she said, adding there were no affordable options for older people who need to downsize.

Another speaker said half of renters were under rental stress, with more than 30 per cent of their income spent on rent. Some said the proposal would create a community, not just housing, that the housing was needed now and for future generations, and that thoughtful, considered development could protect what the community loves about the area.

READ ALSO Coastal council approves plan to turn motel into long-term housing

Mr Fernon said the planning proposal was needed because there was a huge need for smaller homes, that the [6254] additional dwellings outlined in the current draft Batemans Bay Masterplan would not be delivered for many years, that most of the zoned land in Broulee had environmental constraints, and that analysis he commissioned showed council faced a 2258 shortfall of housing lots in the shire compared with its predictions.

Speakers against the planning proposal said it was expensive land, an expensive development with the land unconnected to services, and isolated from employment, shops and services, so not suitable for affordable housing. Others said there was only one road in and out to the flood and bushfire prone area, and that there was enough zoned land for housing in the shire and in Broulee.

Some said that type of development should be in Moruya where the NSW Government is contributing funding, that affordable housing should be in Eurobodalla’s three main town centres, that it ignored all council’s planning regulation and risked council’s reputation with developers who had complied with its regulation.

Others said the proposal was little changed from the 2024 one, and that preliminary comments from government agencies indicated it had not addressed the issues that were raised back then, there was no guarantee that the housing would be delivered, it placed too much pressure on already strained sewerage infrastructure, the extent of the land shortage had not been verified, there was too much reliance on the VPA, and that there was incomplete information for a proposal of its scale and nature.

Councillors agreed and unanimously passed a motion for a supplementary report including written confirmation from the NSW Government about the applicable strategic merit assessment framework.

Free, trusted local news delivered direct to your inbox.

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Capital region by signing up for our free daily newsletter.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

9
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Well said Anna. Sadly NIMBYs and greenies control our Shire.

As a resident I find the number of people speaking on issues affecting their own interests at meetings a total waste of time, resources and money. Is it any wonder progress on Councils housing strategy and building approvals are nonexistent across the Shire, if this is the norm?

For Councillors to delay progress on the subdivision at 207 Broulee Road to proceed to the NSW Government Gateway Determination only to receive more information from staff is unwarranted. It is clearly a tactic to prevent progress in the area and quite frankly, irresponsible given councillors were advised previously that Council were at risk of potentially not meeting their housing strategy’s annual target for new dwellings. If, the planning framework for the Broulee area does not factor in enough new housing estates to meet the needs of families wanting to live in a coastal oasis due its lifestyle benefits, and close proximity (15kms) to the new $330m Regional Hospital, schools and employment opportunities, Councillors need to ask why, and revisit the document as a matter of priority. This would have been a more effective approach to address this issue, not delay the planning process and add additional work to an already overstretched department.

People move to our area to escape city living and for a lifestyle change, that will never change! Therefore, no town or suburb in the Eurobodalla should be flagged as exempt from future growth opportunities if our Council is truly representative of the interests of all residents. The Broulee “village tag” flew off years ago when major facilities and infrastructure were built in the area. And, one overpopulated business area with high rise buildings will only create social discord overtime, which will eventually permeate throughout other parts of the shire, as happens now in the suburbs in our cities. If the outcome for a better economic future while managing population growth, is a priority then housing quotas across the whole shire is absolutely necessary because the current approach is not sustainable.

Trish Hellier1:08 pm 28 Oct 26

On Monday I registered to speak at yesterdays Council Meeting on this item and the Batemans Bay Master Plan. I had looked at the overloaded Agenda and there were another 3 items I would have like to have spoken on but with only 7 minutes for a presentation I kept it to the 2 items.
I received notification I was the 20th speaker (there were 24 speakers in total that had registered) and it had been decided to reduced the speakers time to 4 minutes. I did my presentation in dot point with the number of points I wanted to raise I went well over the 4 minutes.
Yesterday morning I contacted council and withdrew my name from the presentation list..

I understand there is a affordable housing issue in the shire but our area is not alone on this issue.

This land is RUI Farming and Cattle raising land, land that helps with out food bowl. In February 2024 I spoke against that proposal and I am still against this proposal. We went through a lengthy Rural Lands process of approximately 13year.

I noted in the proposal it stated there are “150 operational positions” that needed to be accommodated for the new hospital – who is to say these position will not be filled from residents who live in the area!!! The new hospital will open in March 2027, this proposal could take at least 4/5 years to get it to the approval stage.

I noted it stated in the proposal there was to be a donation for a sports stadium in Moruya, and at yesterdays meeting it was stated that the developers would make a contribution towards the Tomakin Sewerage works – some make consider these items could be seen as a bribe!!!!

On yesterdays Agenda there was a report on the land availability from Brightway Development I challenge the accuracy of the report. There was no mention of the land that is being developed at the back of Northcove Rd Long Beach, there are blocks available at Stage 2 Bay Ridge, Stage 3 has 40 blocks which are over 2,500 sq mts in size with potential of dual occupancy or further subdivision, there is also Stage 4 and 5 to be developed. There is no mention of land at the Oaks Ranch and Mossy Point, there is land at Bavarde Ave. There are 2 unit blocks at Beach Road and one at Casey’s Beach that have a DA approval, there is now for sale signs on these blocks I have been told this is quite common -get a DA approved and then it’s on sold I have been told it is called “DA Flicking”.

There is no mention in the Batemans Bay Master Plan in relation to the traffic in the CBD. The buses need to be relocated out of the CBD NOW, the traffic in Orient Street, Perry Street, North Street and especially the round about at Beach Road into Perry Street is a nightmare. When will Council sort this mess out?
Trish Hellier

cannedbeeria5:17 pm 28 Oct 26

I think the short term issue with the roundabout is because of the widening of the highway and people are using the old highway to access the shopping mall.
There is a LOT of vacant blocks in and around Batemans Bay. Surely a building covenant should be in place that makes development mandatory on all residential developed blocks within a specified period. Yes, the DA process is slow, so if a DA has been submitted, then the clock stops. But once a DA is approved, then there is a time limit for various stages of the development to be completed.
Currently what we have is legal land banking. Developers (and individuals) buy blocks and hold them until the price rises.

Trish Hellier8:20 pm 29 Oct 26

Since Covid this area has grown. I do not believe that the widening of the highway and the use of the highway has caused the problem. The traffic situation is also a problem in Moruya. It will be interesting to see the next Census stats when they become available.

Trish Hellier

Trish, I cannot speak re 20 years but I can state that after 60 years of home ownership under different councils I can state the Eurobodalla Shire Council is the most stupid and incompetent council I have ever experienced. And from different reviewers on this site and speaking to residents I do not think I am alone re this opinion. The words “country bumpkins” comes to mind as they are certainly no where near God’s brightest stars.

To dictate a speaker only has 4 minutes in which to speak on an issue is beyond ludicrous and I can only suspect they do not want to give speaker’s any length of time or chance to criticise them or ask sensible questions whereby they have to give a reasonable and sensible reply to which I feel this Council would be incapable of doing. I have never ever heard of such a meeting restriction before in any government or private sector organisation. Any feeble excuse such as “we don’t want the meeting to last too long” is laughable. Even meetings of MPs in Canberra can go late into the night, Councils have a responsibility to make themselves open to the questions of ratepayers no matter how long this takes. I can only wonder at the mentality of the person who dictated the 4 minute rule.

Personally, I could not allow myself to attend their meetings as I do not wish to share air space with, in my opinion, ill educated people who would not hesitate to treat residents as fools. My blood pressure would hit the roof within 10 minutes, Nor do I bother with their web site as it would be “sanitised”. One only has to live in the area to witness the results of very foolish and unintelligent decisions.

I will assume that most people, like myself, are fed up with hearing about housing from any political party or Council. They have proven to be empty words. As each home takes months to build one knows it would take many years to build the required amount in any area. We have the land available but a slow moving, and mainly useless, council seems to be the hindrance in this area. I would be too embarrassed to say I worked for them.

Trish Hellier9:13 pm 31 Oct 26

Maureen Council have a Code of Meeting Practice normally speakers have 7 minutes, due to the number of speakers register there is a provision that the GM can reduce that time to 4 minutes. Also in the COMP there is a provision that the Councillors have to finish the meeting by 5.30pm.

Unfortunately at this time of year it has been noticed that the Agenda appears to get loaded. There is a view that as it gets closer to Christmans the Agendas get load therefore items tend to be pushed through whether this is true or not I am not sure.

Lets hope that the Councillors saw fit to have a discussion with the GM over this as there would have been a cost to run the extra meeting. I had noticed that the last few Agendas have been fairly “light on”.

Trish Hellier

Rosedale Roughy11:53 am 28 Oct 26

It appears these Councillors can be tough when whining at Telstra but when it comes to actually making a tough decision then forget it. Maybe if the developer promised this would cost Council tens of millions of dollars (like an unnecessary Dam, Community Centre or Aquatic Centre) the drongos would actually make a decision. The motley controlling mob of Councillors are a Green, a Labor and a trio of sad rusted on Liberals. I agree what someone else said that they are the worse Council in 20 years.

Trish Hellier8:48 pm 28 Oct 26

I note your last comment in relation to “someone else said that they are the worse council in 20years” I disagree with this – I replied to that comment – interesting that comment was under a “bogus name also”!!!.

I have watched council since 2010. A few years back there were a lot of comments about Councillors NOT asking questions. I have no problems if Councillors ask questions that includes questions about the coverage by Telstra at Mystery Bay given how much we have come to rely on on the internet.

In 2012 I did a presentation I was respectful, the Mayor did not like what I was saying as I questioned the manner in which a previous council meeting had been conducted, he turned the button off to my microphone, I then stood up and spoke loudly to the gallery, I received a loud applause. Future meetings I took my microphone actually I took 2 microphones – the Mayor soon got the message.
Trish

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.