21 October 2026

Eurobodalla Shire Council could miss its housing targets

| By Marion Williams
Join the conversation
4
aerial view of land

The DA for 207 Broulee Road seeks a rezoning of the RU1 portion, predominantly to R2 Low Density Residential. Photos: Eurobodalla Shire Council website.

Eurobodalla Shire Council staff have concerns about land supply, yields from development, and the council potentially missing its housing strategy’s annual target for new dwellings.

They told councillors at a recent information session when they discussed a development application (DA) regarding 120 hectares at 207 Broulee Road. The land is zoned RU1 Primary Production and C2 Environmental Conservation.

The DA seeks to rezone the RU1 land, predominantly to R2 Low Density Residential, and identify it as a land release area for 685 lots. The smallest lot size would be 300 square metres. Five per cent (35 dwellings) would be for affordable housing in perpetuity, 5 per cent for build-to-rent housing and 10 per cent (70 dwellings) for key worker housing.

Council staff are recommending councillors vote to move ahead with the proposal. If so, it will go to the NSW Government for a Gateway determination.

Council staff member Katrina Fuller said that as part of their assessment of the DA, they had reviewed the Eurobodalla Housing Supply Audit of November 2023.

“We are concerned it is not going to result in the predicted yields shown in that audit,” she said.

READ ALSO Narooma's proposed over-50s development has impacted residents on edge

The assumption was made that 20 per cent of the land would be set aside for infrastructure and 80 per cent for lots. However, that did not factor in native vegetation and the other things that reduce the land available for development.

“So, we need to look at the land supply and make sure we are going to meet the targets in our housing strategy of 310 dwellings per annum,” Ms Fuller said.

Much of the shire’s land is constrained by slope, native vegetation and biodiversity, bushfire risk, coastal hazards and flooding. Over the years, planning and environmental legislation have evolved and are more focused on managing bushfire and flooding risks. The Biodiversity Offset Scheme has also affected the feasibility of developing land and to what extent.

“Because of these factors, the yields in the land supply audit and the figures in the housing strategy, we are quite concerned we are unable to achieve those,” Ms Fuller said.

The council’s director of planning, housing and environment Gary Bruce said they needed to review the assumptions made in the Eurobodalla Settlement Strategy that was signed off around 2006/08 because the changes in legislation meant the yields predicted would be significantly reduced.

He said the applicant had commissioned its own study and found the discrepancy between what was predicted and what may end up in reality was in the thousands.

“We need to investigate this further. That is why we are suggesting this is viable in terms of going forward,” Mr Bruce said. “There are concerns the yields in the settlement strategy are not going to come to fruition.”

The applicant will contribute to the ongoing maintenance of the created public spaces, to the Tomakin Sewer Treatment Plant Upgrade and make a cash contribution to the development of an indoor stadium in Moruya. Mr Bruce said the Broulee Rd development could be two to three years away.

The subject site at 35 Dunns Creek Road is in red and Tomakin Rd is shown in blue.

Councillors were also briefed about a proposed subdivision of the 10.5-hectare site at 35 Dunns Creek Road in Woodlands, between Mogo and Tomakin. The land is zoned RU4 Primary Production Small Lots.

The minimum lot size is 10 hectares. A DA for dual occupancy was approved in 1993. The proposal is to reduce the minimum lot size to three hectares to create three lots while retaining the RU4 zoning.

The site is not served by water or sewerage, and the subdivision must ensure there is room to provide those services.

Councillor Amber Schutz asked whether the subdivision would create a precedent.

Ms Fuller said because of constraints including native vegetation, bushfires, flooding, watercourses and riparian areas, it would be difficult for other property owners to do something similar. The onsite sewerage facilities must be outside the buffer area of the watercourses.

Cr Schutz asked why Ms Fuller said the proposal had strategic merit.

READ ALSO Councillors get first glimpses of revised Batemans Bay Masterplan

“RU4 can range from two hectares to 40 acres,” Ms Fuller said. “The settlement strategy identified the area for a tourism precinct.”

Cr Schutz said with the riparian areas, the site would suit primary production such as crops.

Mr Bruce said there was probably only one additional property that could go down that path of reducing lot size.

“It works for this site and we support it and there is already dual occupancy, so the chances of it being used for agricultural purposes is already low.”

Cr Sharon Winslade questioned having tourism on rural land.

“Do we have tight enough environmental controls?” Cr Winslade asked. “Camping grounds have very specific controls.”

Free, trusted local news delivered direct to your inbox.

Keep up-to-date with what's happening around the Capital region by signing up for our free daily newsletter.
Loading
By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.

Join the conversation

4
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

This article shines a spotlight on a crumbling system under enormous pressure.
On the one hand, we have a local government department trying to meet the housing needs of a local community, and then we have elected representatives and residents protecting their own personal interests by pushing back against every new subdivision (DA) in the area. Add in state and federal governments environmental regulations, bushfire prevention etc, etc, and unreasonable housing quotas placed on every local regional council due to population density in our cities, it becomes very clear that the current LGA system is crumbling under pressure due to too many barriers for council staff to navigate to achieve the desired goals of every stakeholder. If, our Council staff are expected to continually work backwards and play catch up and review every out of date strategy from 20+years ago before they can move forward, which is really quite astounding, is it any wonder productivity and progress on reaching the housing targets are nonexistent across the Shire, if this is the norm?
Hopefully, the DA for the subdivision at 207 Broulee Road did get the green light from councillors to progress to the next phase of the NSW government Gateway determination because as most residents know, there are people in our shire in desperate need of housing and these 2 new subdivisions would most certainly offer the best opportunities for growing families, due to the close proximity to medical and hospital services, schools and lifestyle choices.

One does not know whether to laugh or cry at the antics of Eurobodalla Council. I am convinced the councillors and staff have the updated printing of “Excuses for Dummies” on their desks for them to use when they feel it is appropriate. So let’s keep it simple, shall we? I have raised 3 teenagers so have heard all the excuses ever written!!!

Severe fires and flash flooding take no notice of government regulations. The fires of 2020 were not limited to only bushland areas. Homes were lost in built up areas in Malua Bay – some just off Beach Road into Sylvan. Others at the top of Jarrah Way including the bowling club. Quite a few homes were damaged on George Bass Drive. Despite this, many residents did not sell up as they were prepared to accept this as maybe/hopefully a one-off. All the rules and regulations cannot defeat nature. Decades ago many trees and other vegetation were removed from all areas to create housing communities. If the population is increasing there is no other option but to follow this same path.

Eurobodalla is a large Shire and one does not have to drive too far to see land suitable for building so the excuses are very weak. A Council cannot allow a self interested “applicant” to try and dictate their wishes nor surrender to aboriginal “dreaming”.

On the issue of Council engaging in unnecessary work (which owners of units opposite this corner are in total agreement) on the corner of Corrigans Cres and Beach Road for which a grant of $76,960.00 was given I state the following………

Tuesday 20th October 9am-12pm approx 7 council employees attended the site installing directional signs and preparing the median strip. This strip is not very high and would measure approx 12-15 metres in length.

Wednesday 21st October 7.15am-10.45am doing similar work

Thursday 22nd October 7.15am-early afternoon concrete laid (not much was needed) and cleaning up the site with a few men staying for a while to observe no one accidentally hitting wet concrete I assume.

Although this costing also includes a lighting upgrade in the shopping car park and installing a new street light, one does not have to be a structural engineer or super intelligent to assess this work would not cost anywhere near the amount mentioned above. Therefore, I ask the following. Where does the excess money of this grant go? Does this excess taxpayer money/grant remain in Council coffers?

As this idea (and, of course, they would state it was the decision by TfNSW who were perhaps only going on the information supplied by ESC and not personal inspection) was implemented originally by Tom Franzen (as per his original letter to residents close to this site). I congratulate him on how well he has ignored the petition by those affected and wasted taxpayer’s money on an unnecessary action. The GM should also take some responsibility if he could not see this was a waste of money when more urgent jobs were needed in the Shire. Large trucks delivering to IGA and Icebox now have difficulty when they have to reverse to go back to the lights to turn right towards Malua Bay and surrounds. Only someone with limited intelligence could have planned this action.

It seems the mayor, councillors and staff of ESC indulge in too much frivolous (although they think it sounds intelligent) talking instead of taking affirmative and, more importantly, correct action to improve the Shire.

Jenny Knowles2:22 pm 21 Oct 26

Is anyone surprised? Nimbys and local armchair crunchies abound in our Shire. Boomers and the rusty old retired Canberra no hopers hate change. Those dopes don’t mind a housing crisis.

Trish Hellier12:05 pm 21 Oct 26

I watched the lengthy Council Briefing on this and other issues. I note as it states in this article “Council staff are concerned about land supply and yields for development”, I also note it states 310 dwelling per annum. The facts are where will the builder come from OR is this a case that council staff are hoping to reach that 310 target in ONE build? Land availability is not an excuse to approve 207 Broulee Rd.

In relation to land availability in this shire my view is that the Councillors should be asking for a CORRECT account of how much land is available in this shire, Director Bruce mentioned 60 blocks still available at Long Beach. I am aware of another development on Long Beach Road that backs onto North Cove Road, there are blocks in Stage 3 Bay Ridge, there is the large unit development that has been approved on Beach Road also one on Casey’s Beach both now having for sale signs on them, I am told this is quite common the developer gets a development approved and then on sells the development it’s referred to as “DA Flicking”. There is now a for sale sign on the Bulky Goods site across from the service station on the Kings Highway.

There is land at Oak’s Drive Catalina, Malua Bay, Rosedale, Oaks Ranch, Mossy Point, land south of Moruya (I am sure there are some areas I have missed).

As it is coming up to the end of the year it’s not unusual for council staff to put forward items on Councils Agenda to get approval I reflect on the BB Coastal Management Plan back in December 2022 (CMP) pushed through on the basis of “we need to get the funding approved” in my view this policy was deficient in many ways.

There were other items in this Council Briefing that I feel are most concerning, “Setting a target of no net loss of canopy cover ” ( is this a method of spying on peoples properties in relation to knocking down trees etc?)”. Support for the Greater Southern National Part to reduce Native Forrest Logging. Recognise Walbanja, Brinja Djiringanj peoples in place of Yuin people – WTF – has ALL the Aboriginal Communities been consulted on this? We have the Yuin Theatre at the Bay Pavalion will this mean that will be renamed if so at what cost!!!! I am not sure WHAT these last item have to do with the BIO DIVERSITY STRATEGY (perhaps a good way to sneak things through council for approval!!!).

Trish Hellier

Daily Digest

Do you like to know what’s happening around your region? Every day the About Regional team packages up our most popular stories and sends them straight to your inbox for free. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.